Versione in Italiano QUI

NimbuScope, will the light get through? The setting sun's ray crosses the low, mid and high cloud layers and reaches the tripod on the curved Earth; nimbuscope.com at the bottom

Has it ever happened to you? Clear sky overhead, a few perfect high clouds, tripod planted on the rocks for an hour. Then the sun drops to two fingers above the horizon and disappears behind a grey strip that wasn’t there a moment ago. It’s the situation we landscape photographers hate the most, and at that point you might as well head to the pub.

It has happened to me more times than I’d like to admit, and the culprit is almost always a (not so) friendly bank of mid clouds. It’s so far away that it looks harmless while the sun is still high, then it turns into a wall as the sun gets close to the horizon.

The Earth isn’t flat, unfortunately (I’ve been saying it for years, lol), and because of its curvature every cloud sinks below our horizon at a distance that depends on its height and on ours. From 40 meters above the sea, a low cloud at 1,000 meters meets it about 145 km away, a mid cloud at 3,000 meters about 235 km away, high clouds above 6,000 meters beyond 320 km. If there’s a bank of mid clouds at that distance, on the line of the sun, the light doesn’t get through.

To keep an eye on all this, a couple of years ago I created Clouds Horizon Distance, a free plugin for Windy. You click on your spot and the plugin draws the sunset line and a ring for each cloud height, what I call the Cloud Sunset Horizons. Then you switch on one cloud layer at a time and check whether there’s something where the rings cross the sun’s line. It works, and many of you still use it (thank you!).

It has its limits too, and I know them well because I made it. The biggest one is that the plugin looks at a single moment: sunrise or sunset, with the sun resting on the horizon. About the minutes before sunset, right in the golden hour, it tells you nothing. It doesn’t know the hills, mountains and islands in front of you, and you have to read the answer by eye, layer by layer, like an oracle’s.

So I took the next step: an app. It’s called NimbuScope. And no, the plugin isn’t going anywhere: it was born free and it stays free.

NimbuScope, however, follows the sun’s ray from your tripod through the forecast clouds, over the real terrain and minute by minute, even before sunset and after sunrise. For every minute it tells you whether direct light reaches you; when it doesn’t, it tells you which cloud stops it and how far away it is. You can look at it in four views, and they all follow the time slider as you move it:

  • Map: your spot, the line of the sun and a ring for each cloud layer. The rings follow the sun as you move the time.
  • Panorama: the horizon as you see it from the tripod, rebuilt from elevation data, with hills, mountains and islands, and the forecast clouds above them. The sun slides along its true path.
  • Section: the ray seen from the side, over the curve of the Earth and the real terrain. You see it get through, or hit the exact cloud, with its distance.
  • Verdict: direct light or blocked, minute by minute, with an orange strip marking the minutes of light.
The NimbuScope Map at Neist Point: the spot, the line of the sun and the rings of the low, mid and high clouds with their distances; below, direct light at 16:13 and the time sliderThe Panorama from Neist Point: the horizon towards the sun with the forecast clouds above it and the sun low over the sea; direct light at 16:21The Section towards the sun from Neist Point: the ray seen from the side over the curve of the Earth passes under the high clouds; direct light at 16:21The Verdict at 16:20: direct light, the strip of minutes of light from 16:13 to 16:24, the sunset time and the distance of each cloud layer

The four views of NimbuScope for a sunset at Neist Point, on the Isle of Skye: Map, Panorama, Section and Verdict.

The clouds come from three weather models: ICON-EU from the German weather service, with a resolution of 7 km, for Europe; UKV from the Met Office, with a resolution of 2 km, for the UK and Ireland; HRRR from NOAA, with a resolution of 3 km, for the United States. All three get a new forecast every 3 hours. The app uses the finest model covering your spot, and you can switch to see what the others say. More models are on the way.

NimbuScope has one job only: telling you whether the light gets through or not. The rules it uses to decide aren’t guesswork. I tuned them on real sunrises and sunsets, and I keep checking them against thousands of minutes of sunshine measured by weather stations and against observations in the field.

On the left, sunset at Bedruthan Steps: the sun low over the sea under the edge of a bank of clouds, the sea stacks and the thrift in bloom on the cliff. On the right, the NimbuScope Panorama for that evening: the bank of mid clouds and the sun in the clear strip above the sea, direct light

Bedruthan Steps, Cornwall, at sunset. I took this photo before NimbuScope existed. Next to it is the app’s Panorama with the clouds of that moment run through today’s engine: direct light under the bank of mid clouds, just like in the photo.

Want to know more about NimbuScope and follow how the project is going? You’ll find everything at nimbuscope.com.

NimbuScope is coming soon to iPhone and Android. If you want to be the first to know, leave your email on the waitlist: no spam, I promise.

Join the waitlist

Of course, once the app is out, I’ll publish a more in-depth article about NimbuScope and a PDF guide for using it in the field!

P.S. Already using Clouds Horizon Distance? Tell me in the comments what you’d like to find in the app.